Skip to Main Content
That Meetball Place logo topThat Meetball Place logo scroll
  • (631)-569-5888
  • tmplace1219@gmail.com
  • 54 West Main Street , Patchogue
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
That Meetball Place logo topThat Meetball Place logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards

Our Menu

Main MenuBrunchCatering Menu

Start Here

Super Shareable Apps for the Table

The Great Clambino

$17.00
Super-sized stuffies, baby clam scampi sauce

Obligatory Burrata App

$15.00
You know, burrata, roasted tomato, basil pesto, balsamic syrup

Frito Misto

$16.00
Crispy local calamari, zukes, jalapenos, spicy marinara
Chicken, or the Deviled Egg photo

Chicken, or the Deviled Egg

$16.00
Who came first? Crispy chicken bite, deviled egg, smoked paprika, Mikes hot honey, blue cheese dressing.

Lobby Pot Skins

$21.00
Lobster claw stuffed potatoes, gruyere cheese, a lot of butter

Kung Pow Kauliflower

$16.00
Crispy cauliflower, general Tso sauce, green onion, hummus, sesame

Scampi Wings

$16.00
Garlic, lemon-pepper, parm cheese

Nashville Hot Chicken Bites

$16.00
Nashville spiced chicken, country pickles, and ranch dressing

Giant Bavarian Pretzel

$15.00
The classic Bavarian pretzel, dipped in everything spice, all the dipping sauces

Steakhouse Eggroll

$14.00
Short rib, creamed spinach, mashed potato, chedz, tiger sauce

Tuscan Spin Dip

$14.00
Roasted long-stem artichoke, spinach, cannellini beans, creamy parm dip
That Giant Charcuterie Board photo

That Giant Charcuterie Board

$32.00
A rotating assemblage of local and imported faves. Ask your server for today's provisions

Burrata Stuffed Meatball

$16.00
It's exactly what it sounds like, burrata...stuffed inside a meatball, with sauce, it's really good

Over Stuffed Garlic Knot

$14.00
It's really big...stuffed with ricotta and mozz

Bacon Cheddar Tots

$14.00
These little guys are never coming off the menu! Bacon studded, horseradish sauce, chedz cheese

The Balls

we're not just balls anymore...

The Classic photo

The Classic

$14.00
Our signature meatball blend, smothered in fresh marinara sauce, topped with shaved pecorino, served over paccheri pasta

Buffalo Chicken

$15.00
Organic Ground Chicken, celery, Rouge River Blue Cheese dressing in our signature buff sauce over creamy mac and cheese

Lobster Sliders

$19.00
North Atlantic lobster meat, arborio rice, crushed butter crackers, served on slider rolls with basil/lemon aioli, side of slaw and chips

GGS Pork Sliders

$15.00
Ginger, Garlic, Scallion, ground heritage pork, hoisin glaze, Korean chile paste, sauteed Bokchoy

Veggie Risotto

$15.00
(back after an armed protest about their removal) Saffron rice, broccoli rabe, creamy mozzarella, marinara sauce

Mediterranean Lamb Ball

$16.00
Ground lamb with some spices and stuff, traditional greek salad, pita, yogurt sauce

The Sampler

$17.00
Daily chefs selection of our balls, no substitutions, that chef guy is a pain....

Ya know, for the family...

Our large format balls, because who doesn't want a large plate of balls...serves 4-5...or one fat chef

Brooklyn Sunday Dinner

$44.00
Pasta, meatballs, braised short rib, sweet sausage, this is why you are sitting in this restaurant. Order this guy

Buffalo Chicks w/ Mac & Cheese

$45.00
Creamy shells, buffalo chicken balls, blue cheese, and certain"we put that sh*t on everything" sauce, gorg crumbs, ranch

Lobster Sliders

$56.00
Picnic-style sliders, a ton of fries, slaw, pickles

GGS Pork Balls w/ Ginger Noodles

$42.00
Pork ball, ginger noodle salad with chile crisp and bok choy

Lamb Ball w/ Greek Salad

$47.00
So, the same thing as the Lamb ball... just bigger

Soups

Because sometimes you need more than just balls...

Lobster Corn Chowder

$14.00
Chunks of lobbys, roasted corn, potato, cheese, poblano peps

Roasted Tomato Soup

$17.00
Stuffed grilled cheese, creamy tomato bisque, crema, Aleppo

Crispy French Onion

$14.00
Our play on the classic, onion soup, gruyere, hamburger crouton, a but ton of fried onions

Reale Ramen

$14.00
Crispy pork belly, GGS balls, HBE, chili crisp, green onion, miso broth

Pasta Meetiole

$13.00
Classic balls, white beans, ditalini pasta, crushed red pepper broth

Salads

Because sometimes you need more than just balls...

Shredded Caeser

$12.00
Hydrorganic farms hydro lettuce, creamy ceaser, toast panko, fresh black pepper

Classic TMP Salad

$12.00
An icon is an icon for a reason, Hydrorganic greens, tomato, cukes, red onion, gorg crumbles, white balsamic

Dirty Bird Ranch Chicken Cobb

$16.00
Panko-crusted chicken, tomato, cukes, bacon, egg, blue cheese, ranch, onion

We <3 Beets

$14.00
Organic beets, goat cheese, arugula, pepitas, mandarin orange, mango vinaigrette. 1994, you're welcome.

Sammies

Because sometimes you need more than just balls...

Lobby Grilled Cheese

$27.00
10000% the best item on the menu, lobby meat, kewpie mayo, tomato, arugula, parm crust, gruyere

Super Saucy Secret Special Burger Madness thingy

$18.00
Certified Angus Beef burger, secret sauce, LTOP, bacon jam, chedz, potato bun

Thicc Chick

$17.00
Southern fried chicken thighs, pimento cheese spread, slaw, red pepper fontina

"Meetball" The Hero

$19.00
Classic balls, red sauce, melty cheese, burrata, semolina

Shrimp Po Boy

$21.00
Crispy tempura shrimp, pickle, slaw, boom boom sauce

Chopped Cheese

$18.00
(Don't Forget the Bev) Neva Neva Neva, Chopped cheeseburger on a hero, LTOP, jalapeno, premium American cheese

The Gabaghoul

$18.00
All the Italian meats, tomato, lettuce, red peppers, basil ricotta, onion, white balsamic

The"Oy Vey" Kimchi Reuben

$18.00
Why are you putting kimchi o the good Jewish pastrami? Because it's damn delicious. Kimchi cuke slaw, good mustard, seeded rye

#Staff Favs | Ask your server about our Quiche of the Week (before we run out)

Come Together

..and share these starters

Chicken or the Egg, Deviled Egg

$15.00
Who came first? Crispy chicken stuffed inside our signature deviled eggs with hot sauce, blue cheese and mikes hot honey....yes, please

Pastrami Smoked Salmon

$16.00
North Atlantic Salmon coated in our proprietary pastrami spice, white truffle honey, brie, crispy caper, pickled red onion & micro cress on garlic Parmesan toasts

Obligatory Burrata App

$15.00
You know, burrata, roasted tomato, basil pesto, balsamic syrup

Lobby Pot Skins

$21.00
Lobster claw stuffed potatoes, gruyere cheese, a lot of butter

# Kung Pow Kauliflower

$16.00
Crispy cauliflower, general tso sauce, green onion, hummus, sesame

Giant Bavarion Pretzel

$15.00
The classic Bavarian pretzel dipped in everything spice, all the dipping sauces

That Giant Charcuterie Board

$32.00
A rotating assemblage of local and imported faves. Ask your server for today's provisions

Good Day Sunshine

green stuff

# Shredded Caeser

$12.00
Hydrorganic farms hydro lettuce, creamy ceaser, toast panko, fresh black pepper

Classic TMP Salad

$12.00
An icon is an icon for a reason, Hydrorganic greens, tomato, cukes, red onion, gorg crumbles, white balsamic

Dirty Bird Ranch Chicken Cobb

$16.00
Panko-crusted chicken, tomato, cukes, bacon, egg, blue cheese, ranch, onion

We <3 Beets

$14.00
Organic beets, goat cheese, arugula, pepitas, mandarin orange, mango vinaigrette. 1994, you're welcome

I am the Eggman

(now where did I leave that walrus?)

Biscuits

$14.00
Country Style Southern Biscuit, Fried Eggs, Ham, White Queso, Hatch Chile

# Hangover Potato's

$18.00
Poached Eggs, Shredded Potato, Shredded Short Rib, Cheese Fondue, Sirchia Aioli

Corned Beef Hash Eggs Benny

$16.00
Chunky Corned Beef Hash, Poached Egg, Hollandaise, English muffin

Steak and Eggs

$18.00
Certified Angus Beef, with melted mozzarella, bacon jam and two perfectly sunny side up eggs

ll American Scramble

$16.00
Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Potato, all scrambled on top of our red pepper cheddar biscuit

Avocado toast

$15.00
Whipped Guacamole, Chunky Avocado, Sunny Side Eggs, Crumbled bacon, Lime Crema, Roasted tomato

Pastrami Mami

$17.00
The good pastrami, swiss cheese, dijon hollandaise, kimchi

Eggs, in purgatory....maybe

$16.00
Shakshuka-style eggs, spicy tomato, and olive braising liquid, pita and goat cheese

Gotta Get You Into My Life

(sweet treats)

Hound Dog

$14.00
Banana and bacon stuffed waffle, Nutella and peanut butter drizzle, whipped cream

# Cinnamon Bun French Toast

$14.00
Stop Drooling and order it. Crusty cinnamon bun french toast with cream cheese frosting

Bam Bam Waffles

$14.00
Fruity Pebble and fruit loop studded waffles with cereal milk glaze and whipped cream

Crepe

$12.00
Nutella, toasted hazelnuts, macerated berries, banana, whipped cream

Turnt up Turnover

$14.00
Apple pie turnover, vanilla ice cream, caramel, candied pecans

Yellow Submarines

(and assorted sammies)

Po Boy Shrimp Slider

$16.00
Tempura Shrimp, Creamy Slaw, Spicy garlic aioli

That Damn Meetball Burger

$16.00
Certified Angus Beef burger, Candied Bacon, Chedz, Boom Boom Sauce, LTOP

Short Rib Tacos

$14.00
Chipotle Braised Short Rib, Cotija Cheese, Salsa Fresca, Lime Crema

Lobby Grilled Cheese

$27.00
10000% the best item on the menu, lobby meat, kewpie mayo, tomato, arugula, parm crust, gruyere

"Meetball" The Hero

$19.00
Classic balls, red sauce, melty cheese, burrata, semolina

V- Vegetarian

Appetizers

Obligatory Burrata Plate (V)

$60.00
Serves 8 • Imported burrata (Italian cheese) with extra-virgin olive oil on a bed of roasted mushroom medley. Topped with Maldon Sea Salt and Mike's Hot Honey.

Smokey Sprouts

$45.00
Serves 8 • Charred Brussels sprouts, whiskey barrel aged maple syrup, wildflower honey, and sea salt.

Bushmaster BBQ Wings

$55.00
Serves 8 • Chicken wings with candied bacon, Bourbon BBQ sauce, and blue cheese dressing.

Cajun Lemon Pepper Wings

$55.00
Serves 4 • Chicken wings with Cajun lemon pepper.

Balls

The Classic Meatball

$65.00
Serves 8 • With ground chuck, short rib, pork & veal. Smothered with marinara sauce & topped with pecorino cheese.

Buffalo Chicken Meatballs

$65.00
Serves 8 • With ground chicken, Gorgonzola, onion, buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, and Gorgonzola crumbles.

Lobster Roll

$75.00
Serves 8 • With lobster meat, Abbario rice, crushed Ritz crackers, and basil-infused lemon aioli.

Veggie Risotto Balls (V)

$65.00
Serves 8 • Panko-crusted risotto, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella balls. Served with marinara.

GGS Pork Meatballs

$70.00
Serves 8 • With ginger, garlic, scallion, ground pork, Hoisin glaze, cucumber, and Thai chili.

Pork Tacos

$68.00
Serves 4 • Tacos with pork belly, pulled pork, and candied bacon.

Sliders

Build-Your-Own Slider Bar

$149.00
Serves 20 • Everything you need to build your own sliders, including your choice of 2 ball types, assorted toppings & condiments, and slider buns.

Hot Entrees

Chicken

$65.00
Serves 8 • Corn flake-crusted chicken with mikes hot honey, and chipotle powder.

Sliced Steak

$65.00
Serves 8 • Certified Angus beef slice served over mac & cheese.

Short Rib

$65.00
Serves 8 • With braised beef, a braised beef demi glace, and shallot.

Pan-Seared Faroe Island Salmon

$68.00
Serves 8 • With za'atar crust and rosemary-infused chili honey.

Smoked Brisket

$65.00
Serves 4 • Beef brisket with Boss Sauce.

Korean BBQ Ribs

$75.00
Serves 4 • Crispy ribs with BBQ sauce.

Rubbed Roast Chicken

$60.00
Serves 8 • Black pepper rub chicken with BBQ sauce.

Fried Chicken

$75.00
Serves 4

Country Salmon

$90.00
Serves 4 • Salmon with sweet heat honey Dijon glaze.

Salads

Caesar By Hand Salad

$40.00
Serves 8 • Baby romaine lettuce with locatelli Romano cheese, toasted panko, and Caesar dressing.

BLT Salad

$85.00
Serves 8 • With heirloom tomato, lobster, nitrate-free slab bacon, hemp pesto, hot honey, and sea salt.

Sides

Baked Mac & Cheese

$45.00
Serves 8 • With a crunchy top.

General Tso's Cauliflower

$45.00
Serves 8 • Crispy cauliflower with General Tso's glaze, hummus, and green onion.

Not Your Grandmas Garlic Bread (V)

$32.00
Serves 8 • Semolina loaf with roasted garlic, pesto-infused ricotta, roasted tomato, fresh basil, and mozzarella.

Loaded Mashed Potato

$45.00
Serves 8 • Yukon gold mashed potatoes with beef demi glace, shaves Asiago, bacon, and chive.

Baked Pacheri Parmigiana (V)

$40.00
Serves 8 • Pacheri pasta with ricotta cheese & mozzarella in Marinara sauce.

Bacon & Cheddar Tots

$45.00
Serves 8
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs